League Champions
- 1923- Toledo 4 Palos Hills 2
- 1924- Toledo 4 Palos Hills 2
- 1925- Copper Harbor 4 Carmel 3
- 1926- Toledo 4 Bloom County 1
- 1927- Toledo 4 Bloom County 1
- 1928- Carmel 4 Toledo 3
- 1929- Toledo 4 Bloom County 2
- 1930- Carmel 4 Chicago G 2
- 1931- Carmel 4 Gotham City 2
- 1932- Chicago G 4 Bloom County 1
- 1933- Chicago G 4 Boise 3
- 1934- Bloom County 4 Chicago G 0
- 1935- Quahog 4 Carmel 1
- 1936- Chicago G 4 Palos Hills 1
- 1937- Gotham City 4 Los Angeles 1
- 1938- Boise 4 Gotham City 1
- 1939- Boise 4 Toledo 0
- 1940- Gotham City 4 Bloom County 1
- 1941- Chicago LS 4 Copper Harbor 3
- 1942- Palos Hills 4 Gotham City 0
- 1943- Los Angeles 4 Boston 2
- 1944- Bloom County 4 Toledo 3
- 1945- Chicago G 4 Chicago LS 3
- 1946- Copper Harbor 4 Chicago LS 3
- 1947- Carmel 4 Chicago G 1
- 1948- Copper Harbor 4 Bloom County 0
- 1949- Bloom County 4 Boston 1
- 1950- Copper Harbor 4 Los Angeles 1
- 1951- Toledo 4 Los Angeles 3
- 1952- Carmel 4 Chicago G 2
- 1953- Boston 4 Boise 1
Top 3 picks
- 1924-Al Simmons, Charlie Gehringer, Red Ruffing
- 1925-Lefty Grove, Jimmie Foxx, Mickey Cochrane
- 1926-Mel Ott, Paul Waner, Joe Cronin
- 1927-Dick Bartell, Lloyd Waner, Wes Ferrell
- 1928-Carl Hubbell, Mel Harder, Bill Dickey
- 1929-Earl Averill, Rick Farrell,Larry French
- 1930-Hank Greenberg, Luke Appling, Lon Warneke
- 1931-Billy Herman, Bucky Walters, Ernie Lombardi
- 1932-Arky Vaughn,Joe Medwick,Jonny Allen
- 1933-Dutch Leonard,Bob Johnson,Schoolboy Rowe
- 1934-Bill Lee, Augie Galan, Harlond Clift
- 1935-Wally Moses,Claude Passeau,Buddy Lewis
- 1936-Joe DiMaggio,Bob Feller,Johnny Mize
- 1937-Bobby Doerr,Jim Tobin,Tommy Henrich
- 1938-Lou Boudreau,Joe Gordon,Enos Slaughter
- 1939-Ted Williams,Hal Newhouser,Charlie Keller
- 1940-Pee Wee Reese,Marty Marion,Harry Breecheen
- 1941-Stan Musial, Vern Stephens, Bob Lemon
- 1942-Warren Spahn,Tommy Holmes,Johnny Sain
- 1943-Gil Hodges, George Kell, Eddie Stanky
- 1944-Eddie Lopat,Eddie Yost,Joe Nuxhall
- 1945-Billy Pierce,Red Schoendienst,Sal Maglie
- 1946-Yogi Berra,Ralph Kiner,Carl Furillo
- 1947-Duke Snider,Jackie Robinson,Nellie Fox
- 1948-Robin Roberts,Ned Garver,Roy Campanella
- 1949-Don Newcombe,Roy Sievers,Minnie Minoso
- 1950-Whitey Ford, Vern Law, Gus Bell
- 1951-Willie Mays,Mickey Mantle,Bob Friend
- 1952-Eddie Matthews,Harvey Haddix,Wilmer Mizell
- 1953-Al Kaline,Ernie Banks,Jim Gilliam
- 1954-Hank Aaron,Harmon Killebrew,Frank Lary