League Champions
- 1926-Palos Hills 4 Gotham City 2
- 1927-Hickory Corners 4 Boise 1
- 1928-Nashville 4 Palos Hills 2
- 1929-Gotham City 4 Chicago 2
- 1930-Boston 4 Marion 2
- 1931-Hickory Corners 4 Marion 2
- 1932-Chicago 4 Boston 2
- 1933-Hickory Corners 4 Boise 1
- 1934-Chicago 4 Toledo 2
- 1935-Bloom County 4 Hickory Corners 3
- 1936-Hickory Corners 4 Bloom County 2
- 1937-Bloom County 4 Hickory Corners 3
- 1938-Bloom County 4 Hickory Corners 1
- 1939-Boise 4 Hickory Corners 2
- 1940-Quahog 4 Palos Hills 2
- 1941-Palos Hills 4 Toledo 2
- 1942-Chicago 4 Boston 3
- 1943-Boston 4 Chicago 2
#1 picks
- 1927-Wes Ferrell,Watty Clark,Lloyd Waner
- 1928-Bill Dickey,Carl Hubbell, Chuck Klein
- 1929-Earl Averill, Larry French, Doc Cramer
- 1930-Hank Greenberg,Tommy Bridges,Lefty Gomez
- 1931-Billy Herman, Bucky Walters, Ernie Lombardi
- 1932-Arky Vaughn,Joe Medwick,Stan Hack
- 1933-Bob Johnson,Dolph Camili,Frankie Hayes
- 1934-Augie Galan,Curt Davis,Bill Lee
- 1935-Claude Passeau,Wally Moses,Ival Goodman
- 1936-Joe DiMaggio,Bob Feller,Johnny Mize
- 1937-Bobby Doerr,Johnny Vander Meer, Ken Keltner
- 1938-Enos Slaughter,Joe Gordon,Lou Boudreau
- 1939-Ted Williams,Early Wynn,Hal Newhouser
- 1940-Pee Wee Reese,Harry Breecheen,Dom DiMaggio
- 1941-Stan Musial,Vern Stephens,Virgil Trucks
- 1942-Warren Spahn,Allie Reynolds,Johnny Pesky
- 1943-Gil Hodges,George Kell,Andy Pafko
- 1944-Eddie Lopat,Eddie Yost,Ted Wilks